Category: Uncategorized

Review: Dickey’s Pit BBQ

DickeysBBQ

While noodling around with Google Maps on the iPhone, I discovered that there was a BBQ joint not far from my office that I hadn’t tried yet.  So on Friday, I set out to give it a try.

The place is called Dickey’s Pit BBQ and it turns out that they are a rapidly growing chain.  I hadn’t been there before, but my previous experience in a BBQ chain wasn’t all that great.  So with a little apprehension I stepped up to the counter and ordered my lunch.

They serve the usual BBQ fare of pulled pork, brisket, sausage, chicken and ribs.  I ordered the two-meat platter of brisket & pulled pork with a  couple of sides and a glass of sweat tea.  The food came out quickly and it looked promising enough, but it didn’t much of a smoke flavor and there was little to no additional flavor in the bark.  Having said that, the meat was tender and the portions were generous. 

The side items were probably my favorite part of the meal.  The green beans with bacon and the BBQ beans were very tasty.  And, I can’t say no to a hunk of sweet cornbread.  I also enjoyed their sauce which is served warm from a steam table by the salad & drink bars. 

Overall, it’s the best chain BBQ joint I’ve eaten at and they do have a pretty large presence across the country.  So, if you run into one of their locations I wouldn’t shy away from eating there.

 Here’s my breakdown:

  • BBQ – B
  • Side Dishes – A
  • Atmosphere – A
  • Value – B
  • Overall – B+

Cheers,
Braddog

Tip: Holding Meat Until Mealtime

If you spend any time at all reading the numerous BBQ forums on the interwebs, you’ll see a question asked quite often. “The meat’s done too early, how do I keep it warm until dinner?”  When cooking low ‘n’ slow over an extended period of time, you can run into this situation quite often. 

Photo from the Naked Whiz
Photo from the Naked Whiz

Here’s how to deal with it:

  • When the meat hits the desired internal temperature (you are checking internal temps and not cooking by the clock, right?), pull if off the cooker and double wrap it in heavy duty aluminum foil.
  • Poke your thermometer through the foil so you can continue to monitor internal temperature of the meat.
  • Then wrap the meat in an old towel or blanket for extra insulation, leaving the thermometer or lead from your thermometer probe accessible.
  • Place the wrapped meat into a dry cooler.  Some folks like to preheat the cooler with warm water, but that’s a personal preference.
  • Periodically check the meat’s temperature.  As long as it stays above ~150* or so you should be okay.  Remember the danger zone for meat is between 45*-140* or so.  If the meat spends more then a couple of hours in the danger zone, be safe and don’t eat it.
  • When it’s time to serve, unwrap the meat and serve it as you normally would.

Using this method, I’ve personally been able to hold ~65lbs. of pork butt for 5+ hours.  However, if the meat drops below the saftey threshold I’d recommend you move to plan B.  Pull the pork, refrigerate, and reheat at mealtime.  I’ll cover reheating another time.

Check out a much more detailed description at http://www.nakedwhiz.com/coolerholding.htm

I usually try to error on the side of being too early and pad my start time a little.  Given my choice of having meat done too soon or too late, I’ll take too soon any time.  I’d much prefer to hold the meat than to try to hurry it up.

Cheers,
Braddog

St. Louis Home Fires

Although I’m very happy with my Big Green Egg, I’ve been thinking about a cabinet style smoker for capacity.  A few times I’ve been asked to cook for parties and the like and I just don’t have the capacity that I need to be able to take on those jobs.  So, I’ve kinda been thinking about my next cooker.

On Friday afternoon, I headed out to West St. Louis County to check out a local grill and fireplace shop that I’ve heard about.  They’re listed as a dealer for BackwoodsCookshackTraeger & Big Green Egg grills & smokers, just to name a few. 

The shop isn’t huge, but they have a decent amount of their space dedicated to BBQ gear, including everything from gas grill parts, grills & smokers, smoking woods, charcoal, rubs, and sauces (the rest is dedicated to fireplaces and the like).  I found the staff to be pretty knowledgeable about the gear they sell and when I told them about Grill & Barrel, they quickly turned me onto the St. Louis BBQ Society and some local events that are planned for later this year.

I picked up a few things from the store and I plan to go back and get a first hand look at a Backwoods Party in a couple of weeks.  So if you’re in the St. Louis area, support your local dealer and give the guys at St. Louis Home Fires a shot the next time you’re in need of some BBQ gear.

Here’s their contact info:

St. Louis Home Fires
(636) 256-6564
15053 Manchester Road
Ballwin, MO  63011
2 Miles West of Woodsmill / 141


Cheers,
Braddog

The Long, Slow Burn

When I tell folks that the pulled pork they’re enjoying cooked for 12+ hrs (or longer), I often hear comments like “Wow, how many times did you have to add charcoal?”. People are amazed when I tell them that I didn’t add any and that I got a good night’s sleep besides. So here’s an example to illustrate the burn times that can be achieved with the Big Green Egg.

Over the holiday weekend, I cooked pork butt on three consecutive nights. The last night, Saturday, I fired up the BGE at ~9:00pm for an all nighter. I filled the BGE with lump charcoal almost to the fire ring. The butts cooked until ~2:00pm the next day. At that time, we bumped the temps to 300 degree and put a load of ABT’s on the cooker. At ~4:00pm, I removed the plate setter and continued to cook at 300-350 degrees while I put a couple of chicken breasts on.

All told, the cooker ran for ~20 hours on a single load of lump charcoal.  I accomplished this without the aid of an electronic draft device (i.e. a Stoker or BBQ Guru), just controlling temps with the vents and giving the coals a good stir when switching between smoking and grilling.

So how about it?  How long have you cooked a single load of fuel?  And gas doesn’t count!  🙂

Cheers,
Braddog

Doing the Triple

Like most holiday weekends, I find myself cooking for almost the entire weekend.  But that’s okay, I love doing it.  This Memorial Day weekend was no different.  And for large meals, there’s nothing better than pulled pork.  It’s pretty simple and goes a long way.  (Here’s my method for pork butt/pulled pork on the Big Green Egg).

It’s sort of a tradition for me to feed the guys at work on the Friday before a holiday weekend.  So, Thursday night I fired up the Big Green Egg and cooked two pork butts totaling ~13lbs.  They went on the cooker at 5:45pm on Thursday night and came off around 8:15am on Friday.  That’s one all-nighter in the books.

On Friday, I offered to bring pulled pork to a family gathering on Saturday for lunch.  So once again I fired up the cooker and went with a single pork butt.  (I also fired up theBubba Keg for some bratwurst for dinner.)  This time, a six-pounder went on the BGE at 5:30pm on Friday night and I took it off at 6:30am on Saturday.  That’s two all-nighters.

My neighbor had planned a backyard party for Sunday and asked me to cook pork butt, so ~15lbs. of pork butt went on the cooker at 9:30 on Saturday night and came off at ~2:00pm on Sunday.  That’s three all-nighters in a row.

Even though the BGE does a great job and doesn’t require much tending, I have stayed up late and gotten up early for the past 3 nights.  I’m sure glad it’s raining today, I could use a nap!

Cheers,
Braddog

Impromptu BBQ

I guess there’s really nothing impromptu about a 14 hr cook, but on the drive home from the office last night I decided to put a couple of pork butts on the Big Green Egg and surprise my team with BBQ today for lunch. I hit the supermarket (Schnuck’s had whole pork butt on sale for $.97/lb.) at 5:00pm and by 5:45pm had the egg fired up and steady at 250 degrees and the meat on.

porkbutt-on-the-bge

I left for my daughter’s softball game and returned home around 8:00pm to find the cooker at ~290 degrees.  I used this as an excuse to “tend the cooker” and fine tune my temps.  That means I sat by the cooker with my neighbor and enjoyed the evening until turning in around midnight.  (Don’t tell my wife that tending the cooker isn’t really all that necessary, shhh)

This morning at 6:00am I found the BGE chugging along peacefully at 255 degrees.  God, I love the smell of pork butt in the morning. 

By 8:30, I had the butts wrapped and resting in a cooler for the trip to the office.  I just finished pulling the pork and setting out the spread.  I rang the lunch bell (figuratively of course) and the stuff was gone in nothing flat. 

Next time, I’ll feed the other half of my folks at the other campus.  I guess the day before the July 4th holiday should work for that.

Cheers,
Braddog

Big Green Egg Ash Pan

As I’ve mentioned here a number of times, I cook primarily on a Big Green Egg.  For the first two years that I owned this cooker, I simply used a bucket and the BGE ash tool to rake the ashes out of the bottom of the cooker.  That worked great until I built my new egg table.  Now, it’s impossible to place bucket under the BGE directly, making ash removal a bit tougher.

A friend of mine happened to be in the BBQ store recently and came home with tales of an ash pan that was curved to fit the outside of the Big Green Egg.  So, I acquired one of these for myself.  This works like a champ and has made ash removal much easier now the egg is on the new table.

bgeeap-5
bgeeap-3t

Cheers,
Braddog

Review: Larry’s Pit BBQ – Christopher, IL

Larry’s Pit BBQ is a little joint near my hometown and has always been one of my favorite places to eat when I visit my folks.  This past weekend, we had reason to make the trip and my wife suggested Larry’s for lunch as she’s a huge fan of their baked beans.

It appears that Larry’s business has grown nicely over the years, the building has been expanded and the parking lot improved.  Heck, they even have a drive thru now.  I’m glad to see a local joint like this doing so well. 

One of the things that I’ve always like about Larry’s is their sauce and the relish that they serve on their sandwich (optionally).  They call it “chow” and I think it’s a great twist on the practice of putting slaw on a BBQ sandwich.  Their sauce is a pretty traditional Memphis style sauce, and they have it in both mild and hot varities.

Larry’s serves pretty good pork BBQ, smoked turkey & chicken, and farm raised catfish.  In fact, there were probably as many people eating fish as there were eating BBQ.  I ordered my ususal jumbo pork sandwich with “chow” and their hot BBQ sauce.  It’s funny that I’d never noticed before that their pork appears to be thinly sliced pork loin rather than pork butt or shoulder.  As I thought about it, I believe it’s always been that way but I’m a little more educated on the subject now than I used to be.

larrysbbq



Portions are very generous and their BBQ sandwich plate is served with 3 sides.  Most joints only serve 1 or 2 sides with a sandwich.  The menu is extensive and the prices are very reasonable, giving them high marks in the “value” category.

Here’s how I’d rate Larry’s BBQ:

  • BBQ – B
  • Side Dishes – A
  • Atmosphere – A
  • Value – A
  • Overall – A-

Cheers,

Braddog

Review: Q4U – Frisco, CO

q4u_colorado

I’m enjoying some late spring skiing in Colorado with my family.  Today, my wife threw me a bone and suggested we try a BBQ joint in Frisco, CO. I guess that’s the least she can doing since I’ll spend the next 3 days packing everyone’s skis and gear back and forth from the mountain.

In any event, we wondered into a place called Q4U. I could see smoke rising from behind a picket fence so I had high hopes. Like a lot of BBQ joints, there was a chalkboard for a menu and orders are taken at the counter. My wife ordered a pork sandwich and I opted for the burnt ends sandwich (I won’t mention the kids meals here since they didn’t try the BBQ).

I was a little disappointed to receive a sandwich covered in sauce, but the sauce was pretty good and it wasn’t overpowering. The sandwich was served on a very crusty roll, not what I’d expected.  My wife thought the pork was a little tough. I thought the burnt ends were pretty good and the baked beans were tasty.

I began to wonder what the regional preferences are for BBQ in Colorado.  Am I unfairly comparing Q4U to my own preferences for BBQ?  I don’t know.  I did enjoy the BBQ and at the most basic level, the burnt ends were smoky, had a nice bark, and were very tasty.  Buns & sauce aside, I guess that’s what really matters.

Here’s my final report card:

  • BBQ – A-
  • Side Dishes – B
  • Atmosphere – B
  • Value – B
  • Overall – B

Cheers,
Braddog

Review: Pappy’s Smokehouse

A recent story on the Travel Channel made me aware of a BBQ restaurant in my own backyard that I had yet to try.  Apparently, the restaurant has won Best BBQ in St. Louis by a couple of local publications.  I guess I really gotta pay more attention to what’s going on in my part of the world.

pappy-sized-invert



Nonetheless, I made the journey to Pappy’s Smokehouse for lunch today.  Before leaving work, I looked up their hours or operation only to discover that their hours are variable based on what time they sell out of their various meats.  Apparently they prepare enough meat for each day and when it’s gone it’s gone.  So I headed out with a sense of urgency.  When I walked in, I was greeted by a line that stretched almost the entire length of the place.  

As I watched plate after plate of good looking BBQ being brought from the kitchen, I was greeted by the sight of 3 Memphis in May trophies near the front counter.  I guess these guys really know what they’re doing.  I was also very encouraged to see that the BBQ was served sans sauce but there were three types available as condiments on the table. 

I ordered up a pulled pork sandwich with a side of baked beans and an ear of deep-fried corn on the cob.

img_0027

This was the small sandwich but the pulled pork was generously piled onto a bun.  It was very tender and had a nice smoke flavor.  I opted for their sauce called “Holly’s Hot Sauce”.  They bill it as a Texas style sauce, and I enjoyed it very much.  The baked beans had a nice flavor but I have to say that I wasn’t wild about the deep fried corn on the cob, although it was definitely a first for me.  I also tried a bite of their brisket (one of my lunch pals gave a sample from his plate), and found it to be very good as well.

Like most BBQ joints, the place was minimally decorated.  They had a super wait staff though and I enjoyed the blues music that played while we ate. They were very prompt in getting the food out, cleaning off tables, and ensuring that everyone was satisfied with their meal.  In fact, the owner himself was very visible around the place.

The menu is extensive and they do a very nice variety of meats and sidedishes.  If their catering business is anywhere near as busy as their lunchtime business, then they must do a great business.  

I’ll make another trip here you can bet.  I’d like to try more of their brisket and maybe some chicken, but they’ve got a real shot at being my recommendation as best in St. Louis.  Oh, there’s one other “clear the bar” item for any good BBQ joint and Pappy’s didn’t disappoint.  They serve sweet tea!  ;>)

Here’s my final report card:

  • BBQ – A
  • Side Dishes – A-
  • Atmosphere – A
  • Value – A
  • Overall – A

Pappy’s Smoke House 3106 Olive Street
          Saint Louis MO 63103 
          Email: mike@pappyssmokehouse.com 
          Phone: 314-535-4340
          Fax: 314-535-4337
          Hours: M-F 11-7 or 8 (we sell out around then)
          Week-ends 11-around 4 (we sell out fast on week-ends)
           

Cheers,
Braddog